Speaker Discusses Human Cost of Immigration Policy
Jennifer J. Carrillo
Sept. 13, 2012
BLOOMINGTON, Ill. – The human cost of a flawed immigration system was the focus of
a presentation Tuesday, Sept. 11, at Illinois Wesleyan University.
"Making Human Rights Real: Immigration Policy and Immigrant Rights" was held as part
of IWU's yearlong promotion of a greater understanding of human rights issues. The
presenter, Jennifer J. Carrillo, of Latinos United for Change and a community organizer
at Illinois People's Action, was also formerly an undocumented immigrant who moved
to the United States with her family at the age of 10.
Carrillo spoke to more than 100 students enrolled in classes that are part of the
Making Human Rights Real cluster of courses offered this semester. Students in the
eight courses will participate in a number of joint events to facilitate shared perspectives
Carrillo contends consequences from the North American Free Trade Act (NAFTA), which
took effect in 1994, "has fueled a large exodus of Mexicans to the U.S." As a result
of NAFTA, Carrillo said, U.S. companies have constructed maquiladoras in the free-trade zone along the Mexican border. Maquiladoras are factories that take in imported raw materials and produce goods for export.
Another effect of NAFTA has been U.S.-subsidized agribusinesses flooding the Mexican
market, according to Carrillo, resulting in Mexican corn producers who cannot compete
against the subsidized commodity. "We've seen 2.4 million Mexican farmers unemployed,
unemployable and homeless, who have left their homes in the interior to seek work
at the maquiladoras, which primarily hire young women," Carrillo said. "When work
is not available there, the U.S. economy is a magnet for Mexicans."
Carrillo said there were 4.5 million Mexicans in the United States in 1990. By 2008,
the number had swelled to 12.7 million, with more than half of those people undocumented,
Those burgeoning numbers and the strain on U.S. systems from healthcare to law enforcement
has led to considerable discussion about immigration policy. In particular, a directive
from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and its interpretation by local
authorities has come under scrutiny and was included in a PBS Frontline program "Lost
Carrillo said an ICE "hold" is a request for local law enforcement to keep a person
in custody for 48 hours after the individual is eligible for release in order to facilitate
transfer to ICE. "This is not the same as an arrest warrant," she explained. "It is
a request so that ICE can start an investigation."
She cited instances where people were stopped for traffic violations such as improper
lane changes and then ended up in an ICE detention center in the Chicago area, transported
with shackled hands and feet, having never appeared before a judge and with no legal
representation. "There is the notion that because these people are illegal, their
rights can be trampled," she said, adding such actions are a violation of constitutional
rights which apply to all people in the United States, not just citizens.
"Our organization started to hear about what we consider these human rights abuses
after distressed family members contacted us," she said. Carrillo told the story of
a young woman named Maria whose mother and father disappeared. "When we went to the
jail (to look for them), there was no record of them having been there. They eventually
surfaced after a few days in an ICE detention center in Chicago," she said.
In an interview following the presentation, Carrillo said her job with the Illinois
People's Action is to "dispel the myths surrounding immigration and help educate the
community that these are people, not numbers."
She said one argument she hears is that undocumented people "should just get legal
status and contribute to the system." The problem with the current immigration system,
Carrillo says, "is you can't just 'get in line' for legal status because there really
is no line."
People from Mexico who applied for "green cards" in 1992 are just now being processed,
she said. Carrillo obtained legal status after marriage to a U.S. citizen.
Students and others attending the presentation learned about the opportunity to volunteer
with The Immigration Project, a nonprofit in Bloomington. The Obama Administration's
program of Deferred Action Status for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) offers freedom from
fear of immediate deportation, along with a temporary work permit (that MAY be renewable
in two years). This program is based on the executive branch's discretionary authority
to determine deportation priorities. It is NOT based on any specific legislation passed
by Congress. As such, if the Executive Branch changes their deportation priorities,
this program may be terminated.
The Immigration Project, based in Bloomington, is hosting a registration event for
this program at the Shirk Center on Sept. 21 and 22. Eligibility information, registration
forms, and legal advice will be available at the site.
Prior to the registration event, there will be two different volunteer training sessions
held on Sept. 17 at 4 p.m. and at 7 p.m. Those interested may register online for
one of the sessions at https://www.iwu.edu/human-rights/DACA-registration.html
Contact: Kim Hill, (309) 556-3960