Portfolio Class Worth a Million to Students
Portfolio class students prepare for a presentation.
October 16, 2007
BLOOMINGTON, Ill. – Studying the market trends, researching companies on the S&P 500,
considering long-range performance – these are all practices of any investment analyst.
The only difference in this case is that the analysts are students.
The Illinois Wesleyan University class in Portfolio Management challenges students
to research and evaluate an investment portfolio. Unlike other college portfolio classes,
the stocks these IWU students manage are real.
“Students learning to understand investing through classes is growing throughout universities
across the country, but many of them have undergraduate students use phantom funds,”
said Elisabeta Pana, assistant professor of finance at IWU. “Our students have made
educated suggestions to an actual Client Board. This is not a hypothetical situation.”
The portfolio fund at Illinois Wesleyan is in the form of an endowment, donated in
1992 by Savannah, Ga. businessman C. Leroy Benner, who learned of IWU from his friend,
1949 alumnus Jack Liston. The two decided to provide more than $100,000 for a fund
where students could learn the real impact of investing. Other donations followed,
including a recent gift from the Benner estate. The class was first organized by Mona
Gardner, Adlai H. Rust Professor of Insurance and Finance and former Director of
Institutional Research and Planning for IWU, with support from the late IWU President
Minor Myers jr. and former IWU Board of Trustees Presidents Hugh Henning and Craig
Hart . Students began analyzing the portfolio in 1993, and after years of student
management, the fund now tops more than $1 million.
“This is a great opportunity,” said senior business administration major Michael McQuillan.
“I’m looking forward to going into job interviews and telling them I’ve already worked
on a million-dollar account.”
The portfolio is divided among the students each fall, who research the stocks and
make recommendations to the University’s Investment Client Board in December. “We
look at key companies which represent the marketplace,” said Nathan Rittenberry, a
senior business administration major from Gurnee, Ill., who has been assigned the
stocks pertaining to healthcare. “My group will look at a company like Johnson & Johnson,
as well as reviewing market trends and how our sector is faring overall.” Students
calculate performance in relation to competitors, the sector and the S&P 500 to determine
whether or not the current investments are meeting expectations. Based on their research,
students recommend holding or selling stocks in the current portfolio, adjusting
portfolio weights and suggesting any new stocks to include.
Beyond learning the basics of stock analysis, students earn something they can use
past their days at Illinois Wesleyan, according to retired IWU President Robert S.
Eckley. “The class offers something special to the University,” said Eckley, who taught
the class in the 1990s, and continues to serve on the Investment Client Board. “The
students present to the Board with the expectation that we are going to ask the questions
we would of a professional,” he said. “Unless it’s way out of bounds, we follow the
suggestions of the students.”
“Facing that Board can be a little intimidating,” said George Aliaga, a 2006 IWU grad
who took the class, “but it gives great insight on how corporations can work, and
how to be prepared for those intense meetings.” Now an underwriter for AIG in Chicago,
Aliaga uses the information he learned about stocks for his own investments. “Along
with preparing me for work, the class helped me prepare for life,” he said.
For 1997 alumnus Corey Schieler, the returns of the class were more direct. “I landed
my job thanks to the class,” said Schieler, a senior investment analyst with State
Farm Insurance Companies in Bloomington, who was recommended by his instructor, Eckley,
for the position at State Farm. “Employers look for people who can cultivate critical
thinking skills,” said Schieler, who returns to speak with students in the class and
also serves as an advisor to the Client Board. “This class offers students the opportunity
to use those skills with real consequences in a real-world environment.”
Along with earning lifelong skills, students in the class have the knowledge that
they are working toward a more immediate goal. A percentage of the returns on the
portfolio go toward the scholarship fund for Illinois Wesleyan students. “This is
more than getting a valuable understanding of the market,” said Client Board member
Gil Dorsey. “It’s about letting students see the real effects of their decisions.”
Even during the research phase, students are aware they must keep in mind the objectives
of the Client Board. “The students spend countless hours digging into the portfolios
of these companies,” said Pana. “It is important to have the Board to guide them.
They are vital to us.” Guidelines include staying away from short-term trends and
keeping a company’s ethics in mind. “The students learn it is more than understanding
how well a company performs, but how they function overall,” said Pana. “It is a good
Contact: Rachel Hatch, (309) 556-3960