New Study Examines Impact of Islamic Religion on Muslim Youth
May 15, 2007
BLOOMINGTON, Ill. – In the days since al-Qaeda became a household word, Westerners
have grappled with the distinction between radical Islam and Islam as practiced in
mainstream Muslim culture. To gain insights into the impact of religion on Muslim
youth, the first phase of a long-term study has found that social success is strongly
linked to religious involvement within the Islamic majority nation of Indonesia, according
to the study’s co-author Doran French, professor and chair of psychology at Illinois
This study of Muslim 13-year-olds found a correlation between religious involvement
across many indices of social competence or success. French and his collaborators
found that adolescents with higher degrees of spirituality and religious practice
were more popular with peers, had greater academic achievement, displayed more prosocial
behavior (being helpful to others), had greater self-esteem, and were more able to
regulate their behavior. Those with higher religious involvement were less likely
to exhibit deviant behavior or experience negative "internalizing behavior" such as
depression or anxiety.
French suggested that a key to interpreting these findings is understanding the context
of a homogenously religious culture, where religion permeates society and is a public,
community identity rather than a compartmentalized, private experience as in the U.S.
For example, he said, the team's research assistants would stop meetings to observe
the call to prayers, for which television shows also are interrupted.
"I think within a homogeneous religious society, being a competent person, being a
successful person also means being a religious person," French said.
The team's work didn't compare believers vs. nonbelievers or Muslims vs. Christians,
but variations within an all-Muslim group. Unlike many studies of religion and social
adjustment, which are often based on a single factor such as church attendance, French
noted that their study factored in both the practice of outward religious rituals
and internal spiritual activities such as meditation.
Their research involved 183 Muslim adolescents in Indonesia. Indonesia is home to
the world's largest Muslim population, but has a democratic government and a judicial
system based on Western law rather than Islamic law.
French presented his research, "Islam and Peer Relationships and Competence in Indonesian
Adolescents," at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development
in Boston last month. Co-authors on the work include Nancy Eisenberg and Julie Vaughan
of Arizona State University and Urip Purwono and Telie Ari of Padjadjaran University
in Bandung. Their research is supported by The Institute for Research on Unlimited
Love - Altruism, Compassion, Service at the School of Medicine of Case Western Reserve
University, and by the Fetzer Institute.
Contact: Ann Aubry, (309) 556-3181