Persecuted in Cameroon for speaking his mind, E. Tatah Mentan finds refuge as IWU’s
first “Scholar at Risk.” (Photo by Marc Featherly)
By Nancy Steele Brokaw ’71
Outside, an Arctic blast has sent the temperature plummeting to zero but inside a
classroom in Shaw Hall on this January day the air is warm and the ideas are hot.
Emmanuel Tatah Mentan is listing three major components of President Bush’s national
security strategy on the board.
Mentan turns to the class. “Who can tell me the dangers inherent in this policy?”
he asks. As his students respond, he flashes an engaging grin and provides nods and
words of encouragement. Sparking a free flow of open-minded dialogue about government
policy is an obvious priority for Mentan in his classroom. He remembers inspiring
those same kinds of debates as a teacher in his native Cameroon. The difference is
that, there, it nearly cost him his life.
Mentan’s yearlong visit to campus as a visiting professor of political science was
made possible through Illinois Wesleyan’s participation in the international Scholars
at Risk (SAR) program. SAR is a global network of more than 80 universities and colleges
that arranges short-term academic positions for scholars of any discipline and from
any country who suffer violence or other threats because of their work, prominence,
or exercise of basic rights.
Mentan, who holds a Ph.D. in political science and has 20 years of teaching experience,
is the first scholar hosted by IWU since it joined the SAR network in 2000. He describes
his stay here with words like “stimulating,” “quiet,” and “comfortable,” though when
he talks of his former life in Cameroon, the pain and anger he feels at being forced
to leave his homeland are palpable, as is his longing to return there one day.
A nation of 16 million located in sub-Saharan Western Africa, Cameroon was invaded
and occupied by France and Britain after World War I. It became independent in 1960.
Since that time there have been sporadic movements toward democratic reform, but “political
power remains firmly in the hands of an ethnic oligarchy,” according to the CIA’s
World Factbook. Its national anthem declares that Cameroon is a “land of promise.”
Mentan agrees that Cameroon is, indeed, full of promise — both in terms of abundant
natural resources (oil, cocoa, tea, timber, and coffee) and in its people’s potential.
But, he says, it is a land lacking in promise for anyone with an open, inquisitive
In the village where he was raised, Mentan grew up with exactly such a mind. Born
in 1948, he spent his boyhood “running football” (playing soccer) and studying law
and politics. After completing the equivalent of U.S. high school, Mentan passed an
elite exam that enabled him to attend the university in Yaounde, Cameroon’s capital.
His interest in political science continued, though his specific areas of study were
journalism and mass communication.
“Cameroonian journalists are also political scientists,” Mentan explains. “But after
graduation, the expectation is for one to become a state functionary. To emerge with
dissenting ideas is seen as ingratitude.”
Mentan and education professor Irv Epstein (left) conduct a scholarly exchange in
the lounge of the Center for Liberal Arts. Epstein is a member of the Scholars at
Risk national advisory committee. (Photo by Mark Romine)
After working for awhile as a news reporter in Yaounde, his habit of asking hard questions
quickly landed him in trouble. The government snatched him from his job and sent him
to a radio station in a remote northern region where there was no one with whom he
could discuss his ideas. In fact, many of his colleagues “were spies from the government,”
he says. “They (the government) thought I would cool off my boiling ideas about freedom
of the press.”
Mentan says, “It’s hard to understand in the U.S., but in Cameroon, we have an intellectual
hemorrhage. It comes from the instruments of government control. Some of us are trained,
we come back and then are sent off to where we are useless, even to ourselves.” But
Mentan was not content to stay useless. Without getting the required government approval,
he broke a sensational story about a border dispute between Cameroon and its southern
neighbor, Gabon. “It exploded and was picked up across the nation,” he recalls. “That
virtually cost me my life.” After being tipped off that he was about to be arrested,
Mentan fled across the border to Nigeria with only his books and clothes.
Enrolling at the University of Nigeria, Mentan earned both a master’s and doctoral
degree in political science. With the appointment of a new president in 1982, Mentan
and other exiles were welcomed back to Cameroon as a conciliatory move by the new
president. But despite promises of new freedom, he returned to find the government
was still keeping a close eye on him. After a frustrating year in which he was basically
allowed to do nothing, Mentan was permitted to take a job teaching journalism at the
University of Yaounde. There he met a student, Charity, who became his wife and the
couple settled into what appeared to be a normal life, starting a family that has
grown to include five daughters.
Mentan wasn’t fooled, however. “I felt the government all around me,” he says. With
a family now to worry about, Mentan decided to apply for an exit visa to return to
Nigeria but was turned down. Despite his fears, he continued to encourage his students
to pursue both sides of a story, not just the government’s. Both his academic training
and his convictions wouldn’t allow him to do otherwise, he explains.
Mentan also continued to chart dangerous waters in his scholarly research. Twice,
he had work stolen. One manuscript, nearly completed, examined assassination as a
tool of political control. “A student must have made it known what I was writing on,”
he says. “My office was searched and the manuscript was stolen in the middle of the
night.” Written in longhand, there were no backup copies. He still mourns its loss.
On May 6, 1990, Mentan did a radio interview in which he demanded, he says, “That
for the here and now, the people express their views.” For this, he was arrested,
interrogated, and “tormented” by government officials. “You have to sign a document
in order to be released (from jail),” he says. “If you do not sign it, they will just
take a gun and shoot you.” He knew fellow academics who had met exactly that fate.
Mentan signed the paper without bothering to read it.
For eight years, Mentan continued to teach at the University of Yaounde, with one
eye always over his shoulder. Then, in 1998, he contributed a chapter in a U.S. publication
in which he described Cameroon as a “flawed democracy” and he found himself back in
the government’s crosshair. Adding to the danger, Mentan was also conducting research
at the time “on the torture of people who don’t espouse the (Cameroonian) president’s
point of view.”
In the fall of 2000, the two eldest of the Mentans’ five daughters left to join Charity,
who was working towards a master’s degree in public affairs as a Hubert H. Humphrey
fellow at the University of Minnesota. The Mentans were sensing that the danger in
Cameroon was growing greater and sending the older daughters to join their mother
provided assurance, as Mentan puts it, “that our family would not become extinct.”
Although Mentan and the couple’s three younger daughters desperately wanted to join
them, they had been denied visas and remained behind in Yaounde.
The police attempted to frame Mentan on a weapons charge by giving his children a
tear-gas canister. Fortunately, the children knew to discard it, and when authorities
raided Mentan’s home they found nothing. But he realized that a line had been crossed.
He had been fearful before, but realizing that now his children were in danger as
well made him “tremble.”
Despite the failure of their gas-canister ruse, police soon came for him, anyway,
escorting Mentan from the university to jail, where he was brutally tortured. “The
things they did there, I do not like to talk about,” he says. When pressed, he will
point out scars on his legs from being beaten by an iron bar and tells of blisters
on the soles of his feet so painful they made him cry.
Mentan was released in the middle of the night. Returning home, he knew that he had
to get himself and his daughters out of Cameroon as soon as possible. In January 2001,
U.S. Embassy officials granted him asylum. Although forced to leave his daughters
behind in the care of their grandmother, Mentan hoped that his absence would assure
their safety until arrangements could be made for them to join the rest of the family
That reunion finally occurred, nearly two years later, in Minnesota. Mentan remembers
how his family embraced and wept with the realization that their separation was finally
over. The feeling of relief, he says, was coupled with a profound gratitude that their
faith in God had helped carry them through the ordeal.
Since then, two more years have passed and — after teaching stints at the University
of Minnesota and the University of Missouri, St. Louis — Mentan is delighted to find
himself at Illinois Wesleyan. Upon first arriving here last fall, he says he wondered
if he was dreaming.
“Here were disciplined students, reading under trees, staying in the library until
1 a.m.,” he says. “The students were energetic, attentive, and most of all, eager
to learn, wanting to learn.” He discovered the same energy among the faculty. “I attended
lectures of my colleagues,” Mentan says. “I was excited by their devotion to task.”
Irv Epstein — professor of Educational Studies and a member of the Scholars at Risk
national advisory committee — believes that Mentan’s presence on the campus has more
than validated IWU’s involvement in the program. “Tatah is having a big impact on
Illinois Wesleyan’s campus in terms of making more visible our understanding of African
studies and human rights generally. He’s not simply a wonderful role model for students
and colleagues but also a prescient observer and scholar. His academic insights are
Among those insights, Mentan offers an assessment of IWU’s style of shared governance.
“It’s not someone ‘up there’ who is handing down orders,” he says. “Instead, when
there’s a problem, it’s approached in a clinical, shared way. The camaraderie among
the faculty — this is something I enjoy very much.”
Mentan chats with students in The Ames Library. Mentan compares the atmosphere of
IWU’s campus to a village in his homeland. “We Africans, we like this family feeling,”
he says. (Photo by Mark Romine)
So at home is Mentan at Illinois Wesleyan that he often finds himself walking back
to campus in the evenings from his nearby apartment (“I am a foot runner — no car”).
“I love to read,” he says, admitting he often stays in The Ames Library with the students
until 1 a.m. “I may doze off,” he says, “but then I wake up on the comfortable couch
and read some more.” In general, the feeling of comfort he’s experienced at IWU makes
him feel as much a part of a family as a university.
“I like it here,” Mentan concludes simply. “It’s quiet like a village. We Africans,
we like this family feeling.”
Still, he misses his own family, and travels to St. Paul to visit them whenever he
can. He keeps especially close track of his daughters’ numerous activities and achievements.
The children, now ages 10 to 18, “are so Americanized already,” he observes. “They
are more American-African than African-American.” His two oldest will be starting
college in the fall, probably at the University of Minnesota. He confesses, “I don’t
feel easy, seeing them go off.”
This semester, Mentan is teaching a class on “Human Security and Global Governance”
and a seminar on “Peace and Conflict Areas.” He has done some traveling and speaking
with other SAR participants and has become a passionate advocate of the program and
its worth, not just for him and other “scholars at risk,” but to everyone associated
with higher education. “Academia is like a human being,” he says. “If a finger is
hurt, the danger of infection is a threat to the whole body.”
That theme is echoed in his new book, Dilemmas of Weak States: Africa and Transnational
Terrorism in the 21st Century, printed this winter by Ashgate Publishing in London.
Among other things, this book argues that Africa is in danger of becoming a weak link
in the global war against terrorism. As Mentan puts it, “Africa is both agent and
victim of transnational terrorism.”
In many African nations, the same factors exist that led to the rise of international
terrorism in the Middle East and Central Asia, says Mentan, who urges U.S. policy-makers
to do more to assist economic stability and the spread of democracy in the region.
In a recent interview published in the SAR newsletter, Mentan said, “The process of
democratization in Africa has degenerated. ... Inept, corrupt, and repressive rulers
are reinforcing their grip on state power. There are very slim chances of democratic
forces ever coming to power except by violent means. And, we know that those who foreclose
peaceful change always make violent change inevitable.”
Although he is currently applying for university positions in the U.S., Mentan says
his immediate plans are still uncertain. When the time is right, though, he believes
he will go back to the faraway place that was once his home. “My daughters,” he says,
“if I pull them back (to Africa), their minds will be here.” He will wait until they
“achieve a certain level” of maturity before focusing on his intention to return to
“The evil system (there) must change,” he says, “and it must be fought from the inside.”
Mentan, once the young man with boiling ideas and high ideals, refuses to cool down
or yield to apathy. He will not turn his back on his homeland, despite the problems,
despite the dangers. His struggle is an old one — the journey toward freedom.
“For me,” Mentan says, “if there are no obstacles, life loses its meaning as a struggle
to overcome the odds. However, with God and very concerned people on my side, I shall
always smash the obstacles.”
> To go to the Scholars at Risk network Web site, click here.