Humanity can learn much about
our Universe without enduring
the risks of spaceflight.
By Linda French, Associate Professor of Physics (shown above)
“...To boldly go where no one has gone before....”
At least once a week Patrick Stewart’s Shakespearean voice intones those familiar words on my family’s television set. By now we’ve seen almost all of the Star Trek: The Next Generation episodes multiple times, along with the other series incarnations of the Star Trek Universe. The vision of a mission to explore our Galaxy — shared among genders, races, and even species — inspires my teenage daughter as much as it did those of us who came of age in the late 1960s.
Exploring the real Universe, however, is far more difficult and dangerous than could be conveyed by any number of phaser battles or hostile alien creatures conjured by our imaginations. Simply put, space is big, cold, and dark. We humans are fragile, and our needs for oxygen, water, and food mean that any space-travel missions involving humans will necessarily cost hundreds, if not thousands, of times as much as unmanned missions with the same goals. In the Star Trek stories, we are clearly given to understand that war, poverty, and hunger have been eliminated (along with, apparently, national boundaries) by the time of the Enterprise’s mission. It is well that we remember how much the idealistic conditions differ from those of our present world.
Why does an astronomer sound so bleak about the prospects for manned spaceflight? Don’t we need to send people into space to learn more about our galactic neighborhood — our Solar System, our Galaxy, and beyond?
|This panoramic image mosaic taken by the Mars Exploration Rover Spirit, shows the rover's destination toward the hill range nicknamed "Columbia Hills." (NASA)|
The fascination that these questions hold for both scientists and the general public shows an interest in exploration akin to that of the crew of the Enterprise at a fraction of the cost, and at no risk to human life. Unmanned probes have shown us that the surface of Venus, under its dense clouds of carbon dioxide and sulfuric acid, is geologically active. Its 800-degree surface temperature, so different from that of our Earth, is caused by a runaway greenhouse effect. The research which led to this understanding has helped us better comprehend the implications for greenhouse gases in our own atmosphere. Unmanned probes have shown us the rings and moons of the great giant planets Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune. We have seen a moon with more than a dozen active volcanoes (Jupiter’s Io), a moon with an ocean of liquid nitrogen (Saturn’s Titan, soon to be visited by a probe from the Cassini spacecraft), and perhaps most evocatively, a moon with an ocean of liquid water protected by a frozen crust (Jupiter’s Europa). Only Pluto has yet to be visited by a spacecraft, and that mission is planned within the next 20 years.
Many other exciting discoveries have come from old-fashioned ground-based astronomy, aided by the incredibly successful orbiting Hubble Space Telescope. An entirely new solar system population, the Kuiper Belt, has been discovered far from the Sun; there are probably millions of these objects, and astronomers literally cannot keep up with them. The collision of Comet Shoemaker-Levy 9 with Jupiter in 1994 made clear that collisions do happen in the Solar System today; a network of small telescopes has made great strides in finding and cataloging objects which could someday crash into the Earth.
|This view of nearly 10,000 galaxies is the deepest visible-light image of the cosmos. Called the Hubble Ultra Deep Field, this galaxy-studded view represents a "deep" core sample of the Universe, cutting across billions of light-years. (NASA)|
Perhaps, if you have read this far, I do not need to justify such research, but I would like to share why I find it so exciting. I have always had an interest in what’s going on in my backyard. Is that a purple finch or a house finch at the feeder? Is the tree with the nice colors a red maple or a silver maple? What star is so bright right overhead at sunset during the summer? For me, and for many others, this curiosity about our surroundings naturally extends outward and upward. If one knows just where to look, our nearest large galactic neighbor, the Andromeda Galaxy, can be seen with the naked eye. This faint, fuzzy patch leads us to contemplate the swirling conglomeration of galaxies of which our planet is but an infinitesimal part.When we look at astronomical objects, we ask not only “What is that?” but also “What was the Universe like at an earlier time?” When I study asteroids and comets, I am sampling material from the earliest days of the Solar System. When astronomers study the expansion of the Universe, they use telescopes as “time machines” to peer back billions of years, observing what the first galaxies looked like. These questions, I submit, are in the same spirit of adventure that drives the fictional crew of the Enterprise, at far less cost and risk to human life.
Am I saying that we — the citizens of Earth — should not consider a return to the Moon, or an eventual mission to Mars? Absolutely not. But missions like these are enormous, and only the combined mental and physical resources of an entire planet are likely to be able to carry them off. In the meantime, as we work together to settle our differences, we humans can learn much about our world through collaboration in unmanned missions and traditional observing programs that will enlighten and inspire us all to go, cautiously and prudently, where no humans have gone before.
> To read about a recent trip to an observatory in Chile taken by Professor French and one of her students, click here.
> To read about a class on extraterrestrial life taught by Linda French, click here.