| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Iwu40 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Iwu40 | Ladd, Kraig sacked for loss of 12 yards to the IWU28 (Laizure, Jesse). |
| Iwu | 2-22 | on Iwu28 | Ladd, Kraig pass complete to Ceisel, Martin for 32 yards to the WHEATON40, 1ST DOWN IWU (Ittersagen, P.). |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Wheaton40 | Winston, Christ rush for 5 yards to the WHEATON35 (Toal, Jonathan;Kuenzle, Ben). |
| Iwu | 2-5 | on Wheaton35 | Ladd, Kraig pass incomplete to Scalcucci, Jack (Langs, Tyler). |
| Iwu | 3-5 | on Wheaton35 | Dunlop, Marcus rush for 20 yards to the WHEATON15, 1ST DOWN IWU (Langs, Tyler). |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Wheaton15 | Timeout Wheaton, clock 12:42. |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Wheaton15 | Ladd, Kraig pass incomplete to Almanzo, Tom. |
| Iwu | 2-10 | on Wheaton15 | Ladd, Kraig pass complete to Sandrik, Matt for 14 yards to the WHEATON1, 1ST DOWN IWU (Roszkowiak, G.). |
| Iwu | 1-G | on Wheaton01 | Ladd, Kraig rush for 1 yard to the WHEATON0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:24. |
| | | Ladd, Kraig pass attempt failed. |
| Wheaton 14, Illinois Wesleyan 12 |
| | Drive: 11 plays, 72 yards, TOP 3:26 |
| | | Tiefenbruck, Br kickoff 59 yards to the WHEATON11, Pokorny, Alex return 13 yards to the WHEATON24 (Crouch, Adam). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | on Wheaton24 | WHEATON drive start at 12:17. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | on Wheaton24 | Norris, Sean pass incomplete to Bradley, Matt. |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | on Wheaton24 | Norris, Sean pass complete to Jackson, Brett for no gain to the WHEATON24 (Osburn, Bo). |
| Wheaton | 3-10 | on Wheaton24 | Norris, Sean rush for no gain to the WHEATON24 (Welke, Charlie;Nikolich, Nick). |
| Wheaton | 4-10 | on Wheaton24 | Norris, Sean punt 43 yards to the IWU33, Scalcucci, Jack return 9 yards to the IWU42 (Latsha, Brett;Ryan, Jon). |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 1:42 |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Iwu42 | ILLINOIS WESLEYAN drive start at 10:35. |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Iwu42 | Ladd, Kraig pass incomplete. |
| Iwu | 2-10 | on Iwu42 | Dunlop, Marcus rush for loss of 1 yard to the IWU41 (Pagh, Steve). |
| Iwu | 3-11 | on Iwu41 | Ladd, Kraig rush for 5 yards to the IWU46 (Laizure, Jesse). |
| Iwu | 4-6 | on Iwu46 | Vizza, Sam punt 34 yards to the WHEATON20, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 1:34 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | on Wheaton20 | WHEATON drive start at 09:01. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | on Wheaton20 | Hershey, Andrew rush for 1 yard to the WHEATON21 (Hoyland, Rob). |
| Wheaton | 2-9 | on Wheaton21 | Hershey, Andrew rush for loss of 1 yard to the WHEATON20 (Osburn, Bo;Nikolich, Nick). |
| Wheaton | 3-10 | on Wheaton20 | Norris, Sean pass incomplete to Pokorny, Alex. |
| Wheaton | 4-10 | on Wheaton20 | Norris, Sean punt 43 yards to the IWU37, Scalcucci, Jack return 11 yards to the IWU48 (Ryan, Jon;Pokorny, Alex). |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 1:30 |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Iwu48 | ILLINOIS WESLEYAN drive start at 07:31. |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Iwu48 | Winston, Christ rush for 1 yard to the IWU49 (Langs, Tyler). |
| Iwu | 2-9 | on Iwu49 | Ladd, Kraig pass incomplete to Winston, Christ. |
| Iwu | 3-9 | on Iwu49 | Ladd, Kraig pass complete to Sandrik, Matt for 7 yards to the WHEATON44 (Laizure, Jesse). |
| Iwu | 4-2 | on Wheaton44 | Ladd, Kraig pass complete to Sandrik, Matt for 14 yards to the WHEATON30, 1ST DOWN IWU (Tokar, David). |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Wheaton30 | Dunlop, Marcus rush for 30 yards to the WHEATON0, 1ST DOWN IWU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:43. |
| | | Ladd, Kraig pass attempt failed. |
| Illinois Wesleyan 18, Wheaton 14 |
| | Drive: 5 plays, 52 yards, TOP 1:48 |
| | | Tiefenbruck, Br kickoff 47 yards to the WHEATON23, Pokorny, Alex return 15 yards to the WHEATON38 (Kotz, Mike). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | on Wheaton38 | WHEATON drive start at 05:38. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | on Wheaton38 | Norris, Sean pass incomplete to Pokorny, Alex (Dulaney, Andrew). |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | on Wheaton38 | Norris, Sean pass complete to Dreyer, Noah for 7 yards to the WHEATON45 (Nikolich, Nick). |
| Wheaton | 3-3 | on Wheaton45 | Jackson, Brett rush for 6 yards to the IWU49, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Souder, Dan;Smith, Brian). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | on Iwu49 | Norris, Sean pass incomplete to Pokorny, Alex. |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | on Iwu49 | Norris, Sean pass incomplete to Ellis, Freddy (Hunter, Roman). |
| Wheaton | 3-10 | on Iwu49 | Norris, Sean pass incomplete. |
| Wheaton | 4-10 | on Iwu49 | Norris, Sean punt 38 yards to the IWU11, fair catch by Scalcucci, Jack. |
| | Drive: 6 plays, 13 yards, TOP 0:51 |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Iwu11 | ILLINOIS WESLEYAN drive start at 04:47. |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Iwu11 | Dunlop, Marcus rush for loss of 1 yard to the IWU10 (Pagh, Steve). |
| Iwu | 2-11 | on Iwu10 | Ladd, Kraig pass complete to Podkowa, Rick for 28 yards to the IWU38, 1ST DOWN IWU (Woodward, Shane). |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Iwu38 | Dunlop, Marcus rush for 2 yards to the IWU40 (Theisen, Eric;Pagh, Steve). |
| Iwu | 2-8 | on Iwu40 | Dunlop, Marcus rush for 20 yards to the WHEATON40, 1ST DOWN IWU (Woodward, Shane). |
| Iwu | 1-10 | on Wheaton40 | Dunlop, Marcus rush for 5 yards to the WHEATON35 (Almanza, Javier). |
| Iwu | 2-5 | on Wheaton35 | Dunlop, Marcus rush for no gain to the WHEATON35 (Laizure, Jesse). |
| Iwu | 3-5 | on Wheaton35 | Timeout Wheaton, clock 01:37. |
| Iwu | 3-5 | on Wheaton35 | Dunlop, Marcus rush for loss of 5 yards to the WHEATON40 (Woodward, Shane). |
| Iwu | 4-10 | on Wheaton40 | Timeout Illinois Wesleyan, clock 00:43. |
| Iwu | 4-10 | on Wheaton40 | Vizza, Sam punt 27 yards to the WHEATON13, Ittersagen, P. return 5 yards to the WHEATON18 (McGhee, Donnie). |
| | Drive: 7 plays, 49 yards, TOP 4:14 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | on Wheaton18 | WHEATON drive start at 00:33. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | on Wheaton18 | Norris, Sean pass complete to Jackson, Brett for 6 yards to the WHEATON24 (Welke, Charlie). |
| Wheaton | 2-4 | on Wheaton24 | Norris, Sean pass incomplete. |
| Wheaton | 3-4 | on Wheaton24 | Norris, Sean pass complete to Bradley, Matt for 12 yards to the WHEATON36, 1ST DOWN WHEATON. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | on Wheaton36 | Norris, Sean pass incomplete. |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | on Wheaton36 | Norris, Sean pass incomplete. |
| Wheaton | 3-10 | on Wheaton36 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | Drive: 5 plays, 18 yards, TOP 0:33 |
