| Carthage 1st |
| Baitinger, B singled up the middle. |
| Baitinger, B stole second. |
| Dropped foul ball, E2. |
| Creekmore, T singled to right field, RBI; Baitinger, B scored. |
| Acevado, J homered to center field, 2 RBI; Creekmore, T scored, unearned. |
| Hughes, Mike singled up the middle. |
| McGuire, M. struck out looking. |
| Hermes, D hit by pitch; Hughes, Mike advanced to second. |
| Albers, Josh reached on a fielder's choice; Hermes, D out on the play, out at second ss to 2b; Hughes, Mike advanced to third. |
| Sobol, Mark struck out looking. |
| 3 runs, 4 hits, 1 error, 2 LOB. |
| Illinois Wesleyan 1st |
| Rittenberry singled through the right side. |
| McInerney flied out to cf. |
| Angel lined out to 2b. |
| Ladd doubled to left field, RBI; Rittenberry scored. |
| McIntosh popped up to 2b. |
| 1 run, 2 hits, 0 errors, 1 LOB. |
| Carthage 2nd |
| Ferro, Joe struck out swinging. |
| Baitinger, B doubled down the lf line. |
| Creekmore, T struck out swinging. |
| Acevado, J out at first 1b to p. |
| 0 runs, 1 hit, 0 errors, 1 LOB. |
| Illinois Wesleyan 2nd |
| Goshorn struck out swinging. |
| Kwiatkowski struck out swinging. |
| Marzec struck out swinging. |
| 0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors, 0 LOB. |
| Carthage 3rd |
| Hughes, Mike flied out to cf. |
| McGuire, M. struck out swinging. |
| Hermes, D homered to left field, RBI. |
| Albers, Josh flied out to cf. |
| 1 run, 1 hit, 0 errors, 0 LOB. |
| Illinois Wesleyan 3rd |
| Morrissey doubled to center field. |
| Rittenberry grounded out to 1b unassisted; Morrissey advanced to third. |
| McInerney hit by pitch. |
| Angel doubled to right field, RBI; McInerney advanced to third; Morrissey scored. |
| Ladd fouled out to 3b. |
| McIntosh grounded out to 3b. |
| 1 run, 2 hits, 0 errors, 2 LOB. |
| Carthage 4th |
| Sobol, Mark flied out to lf. |
| Ferro, Joe struck out looking. |
| Baitinger, B grounded out to ss. |
| 0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors, 0 LOB. |
| Illinois Wesleyan 4th |
| Goshorn struck out swinging, out at first c to 1b. |
| Kwiatkowski fouled out to 1b. |
| Marzec walked. |
| Marzec out at second c to ss, caught stealing. |
| 0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors, 0 LOB. |
| Carthage 5th |
| Creekmore, T flied out to cf. |
| Acevado, J walked. |
| Hughes, Mike struck out swinging. |
| McGuire, M. grounded out to 3b. |
| 0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors, 1 LOB. |
| Illinois Wesleyan 5th |
| Morrissey homered to center field, RBI. |
| Rittenberry singled through the left side. |
| McInerney singled; Rittenberry advanced to second. |
| Angel infield fly to 2b. |
| Ladd singled to center field; McInerney advanced to second; Rittenberry advanced to third. |
| McIntosh singled to left field, 2 RBI; Ladd advanced to second; McInerney scored; Rittenberry scored. |
| Goshorn grounded into double play 3b to 2b to 1b; McIntosh out on the play. |
| 3 runs, 5 hits, 0 errors, 1 LOB. |
| Carthage 6th |
| Garvey to c for Kwiatkowski. |
| Hermes, D struck out looking. |
| Albers, Josh lined out to 3b. |
| Sobol, Mark struck out looking. |
| 0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors, 0 LOB. |
| Illinois Wesleyan 6th |
| Garvey walked. |
| Marzec lined out to cf. |
| Morrissey singled down the lf line; Garvey advanced to second. |
| Rittenberry flied out to cf. |
| Kieffer, B to p for Maher, Mike. |
| McInerney singled to center field, RBI; Morrissey advanced to second; Garvey scored. |
| Angel doubled to right field, 2 RBI; McInerney scored; Morrissey scored. |
| Ladd doubled to right center, RBI; Angel scored. |
| McIntosh popped up to ss. |
| 4 runs, 4 hits, 0 errors, 1 LOB. |
| Carthage 7th |
| Angel to 1b. |
| Moore to 2b for McIntosh. |
| Romano, Seth pinch hit for Ferro, Joe. |
| Romano, Seth hit by pitch. |
| Baitinger, B flied out to rf. |
| Romano, Seth advanced to second on a wild pitch. |
| Creekmore, T flied out to lf. |
| Acevado, J singled to left field; Romano, Seth advanced to third. |
| Hughes, Mike walked; Acevado, J advanced to second. |
| McGuire, M. singled to right field, 2 RBI; Hughes, Mike advanced to third; Acevado, J scored; Romano, Seth scored. |
| Hermes, D flied out to cf. |
| 2 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors, 2 LOB. |
| Illinois Wesleyan 7th |
| Romano, Seth to ss. |
| Huppert to dh for Goshorn. |
| Huppert flied out to cf. |
| Garvey singled to center field. |
| Marzec singled to pitcher; Garvey advanced to second. |
| Henning, A to p for Kieffer, B. |
| Morrissey walked; Marzec advanced to second; Garvey advanced to third. |
| Rittenberry reached on a fielder's choice, RBI; Morrissey out on the play, out at second 3b to 2b; Marzec advanced to third; Garvey scored. |
| McInerney doubled to left field, 2 RBI; Rittenberry scored; Marzec scored. |
| McInerney advanced to third on a wild pitch. |
| Angel singled through the right side, RBI; McInerney scored. |
| Ladd singled, advanced to second; Angel advanced to third, scored on an error by lf, unearned. |
| Moore reached on an error by 3b; Ladd advanced to third. |
| Huppert homered to left center, 3 RBI, unearned; Moore scored, unearned; Ladd scored, unearned. |
| Dahm, Dan to p for Henning, A. |
| Garvey singled to pitcher. |
| Marzec reached on an error by 3b; Garvey advanced to second. |
| Morrissey reached on a fielder's choice; Marzec out on the play, out at second ss to 2b. |
| 8 runs, 7 hits, 3 errors, 2 LOB. |
| Carthage 8th |
| McCreary to p for Page. |
| Albers, Josh reached on an error by 3b. |
| Sobol, Mark grounded out to ss; Albers, Josh advanced to second. |
| Romano, Seth grounded out to ss; Albers, Josh advanced to third. |
| Shannon, C pinch hit for Baitinger, B. |
| Shannon, C flied out to rf. |
| 0 runs, 0 hits, 1 error, 1 LOB. |
| Illinois Wesleyan 8th |
| Shannon, C to cf. |
| Coughlin, S to rf for Creekmore, T. |
| Gragnani, T to 2b for Acevado, J. |
| McGuire, M. to 1b. |
| Albers, Josh to 3b. |
| Rittenberry flied out to cf. |
| Capazolli pinch hit for McInerney. |
| Capazolli singled to center field. |
| Grodecki pinch hit for Angel. |
| Grodecki struck out swinging. |
| Capazolli advanced to second on a wild pitch. |
| Ladd singled to center field; Capazolli advanced to third. |
| Moore reached on a fielder's choice; Ladd out on the play, out at second ss to 2b. |
| 0 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors, 2 LOB. |
| Carthage 9th |
| Capazolli to cf. |
| Grodecki to 1b. |
| Froelich to p for McCreary. |
| Coughlin, S grounded out to 1b unassisted. |
| Gragnani, T doubled to right field. |
| Hansen, Tim pinch hit for Hughes, Mike. |
| Hansen, Tim singled to center field, RBI; Gragnani, T scored. |
| Buswell, K pinch hit for McGuire, M.. |
| Buswell, K grounded out to ss; Hansen, Tim advanced to second. |
| Hodges, Will pinch hit for Hermes, D. |
| Hodges, Will struck out swinging. |
| 1 run, 2 hits, 0 errors, 1 LOB. |