1922 Illinois Wesleyan 24, Wheaton 0
1947 Wheaton 49, Illinois Wesleyan 13
1948 Illinois Wesleyan 20, Wheaton 6
1949 Wheaton 13, Illinois Wesleyan 7
1952 Wheaton 32, Illinois Wesleyan 6
1954 Illinois Wesleyan 9, Wheaton 7
1955 Wheaton 14, Illinois Wesleyan 0
1956 Wheaton 14, Illinois Wesleyan 6
1957 Wheaton 67, Illinois Wesleyan 6
1958 Wheaton 37, Illinois Wesleyan 14
1959 Wheaton 44, Illinois Wesleyan 0
1962 Wheaton 33, Illinois Wesleyan 14
1965 Illinois Wesleyan 33, @ Wheaton 0
1966 Illinois Wesleyan 20, Wheaton 18
1968 Illinois Wesleyan 21, @ Wheaton 0
1970 (tie) Illinois Wesleyan 21, Wheaton 21
1971 Illinois Wesleyan 33, @ Wheaton 14
1972 Illinois Wesleyan 49, Wheaton 6
1973 Illinois Wesleyan 22, @ Wheaton 0
1974 Illinois Wesleyan 21, Wheaton 7
1975 Illinois Wesleyan 16, @ Wheaton 15
1976 Illinois Wesleyan 21, Wheaton 7
1977 @ Wheaton 10, Illinois Wesleyan 9
1978 @ Wheaton 31, Illinois Wesleyan 14
1979 Illinois Wesleyan 14, @ Wheaton 7
1980 Illinois Wesleyan 20, Wheaton 17
1981 Illinois Wesleyan 19, @ Wheaton 6
1982 Illinois Wesleyan 21, Wheaton 20
1983 @ Wheaton 16, Illinois Wesleyan 14
1984 Illinois Wesleyan 34, Wheaton 10
1985 @ Wheaton 30, Illinois Wesleyan 29
1986 Wheaton 35, Illinois Wesleyan 12
1987 @ Wheaton 27, Illinois Wesleyan 21
1988 Wheaton 27, Illinois Wesleyan 10
1989 @ Wheaton 27, Illinois Wesleyan 0
1990 Illinois Wesleyan 34, Wheaton 19
1991 (tie) Illinois Wesleyan 24, @ Wheaton 24
1992 Illinois Wesleyan 33, @ Wheaton 19
1993 Wheaton 13, Illinois Wesleyan 9
1994 Illinois Wesleyan 27, @ Wheaton 17
1995 Wheaton 42, Illinois Wesleyan 28
1996 Illinois Wesleyan 64, @ Wheaton 35
1997 Wheaton 39, Illinois Wesleyan 29
1998 @ Wheaton 42, Illinois Wesleyan 28
1999 Wheaton 22, Illinois Wesleyan 20
2000 @ Wheaton 35, Illinois Wesleyan 21
2001 Illinois Wesleyan 31, Wheaton 13
2002 Wheaton 35, Illinois Wesleyan 21