1926 Illinois Wesleyan 6, Carthage 0
1927 Illinois Wesleyan 13, Carthage 6
1948 Illinois Wesleyan 21, Carthage 13
1950 Illinois Wesleyan 49, Carthage 0
1960 Illinois Wesleyan 31, Carthage 21
1961 Carthage 33, Illinois Wesleyan 13
1962 Carthage 28, Illinois Wesleyan 7
1963 Carthage 42, Illinois Wesleyan 19
1964 Illinois Wesleyan 16, Carthage 0
1965 Illinois Wesleyan 37, @ Carthage 13
1966 Illinois Wesleyan 32, Carthage 7
1967 @ Carthage 23, Illinois Wesleyan 14
1968 Carthage 20, Illinois Wesleyan 13
1969 @ Carthage 35, Illinois Wesleyan 0
1970 @ Carthage 34, Illinois Wesleyan 21
1971 Carthage 22, Illinois Wesleyan 19
1972 @ Carthage 60, Illinois Wesleyan 21
1973 Carthage 27, Illinois Wesleyan 7
1974 Illinois Wesleyan 10, @ Carthage 7
1975 Carthage 7, Illinois Wesleyan 6
1976 Illinois Wesleyan 16, @ Carthage 7
1977 Illinois Wesleyan 21, Carthage 16
1978 Illinois Wesleyan 35, @ Carthage 30
1979 Illinois Wesleyan 19, Carthage 3
1980 Illinois Wesleyan 17, @ Carthage 13
1981 Carthage 29, Illinois Wesleyan 7
1982 Illinois Wesleyan 32, @ Carthage 10
1983 Illinois Wesleyan 30, Carthage 7
1984 Illinois Wesleyan 28, @ Carthage 17
1985 Illinois Wesleyan 19, Carthage 18
1986 Illinois Wesleyan 16, @ Carthage 0
1987 Illinois Wesleyan 26, Carthage 19
1988 @ Carthage 7, Illinois Wesleyan 0
1989 Illinois Wesleyan 51, Carthage 20
1990 Illinois Wesleyan 49, @ Carthage 23
1991 Illinois Wesleyan, Carthage 0
1992 Illinois Wesleyan 63, Carthage 8
1993 Illinois Wesleyan 21, Illinois Wesleyan 20
1994 Illinois Wesleyan 55, Carthage 12
1995 Illinois Wesleyan 35, @ Carthage 7
1996 Illinois Wesleyan 42, Carthage 0
1997 Illinois Wesleyan 30, @ Carthage 7
1998 Illinois Wesleyan 37, Carthage 16
1999 Illinois Wesleyan 44, @ Carthage 27
2000 @ Illinois Wesleyan 44, Carthage 13
2001 Illinois Wesleyan 32, @ Carthage 0
2002 @ Carthage 21, Illinois Wesleyan 20