Illinois Wesleyan Softball Year-by-Year
| YEAR | COACH | W-L | PCT. | CCIW W-L | PCT. | MOST VALUABLE | MOST IMPROVED |
| 1977 | Kathy Argo | 4-2 | .667 | Diane Fornoff | Kathy Payne | ||
| 1978 | Kathy Argo | 6-5 | .545 | LuAnn Opperman | Dona Milkinovich | ||
| 1979 | Kathy Argo | 4-10 | .286 | LuAnn Opperman | Marci Anleitner | ||
| 1980 | Barb Cothren | 1-13 | .071 | Jean Worland | Kay Rasche | ||
| 1981 | Barb Cothren | 3-13 | .188 | J.Lloyd, L.Schmidt | Patty Barney | ||
| 1982 | Barb Cothren | 3-8 | .280 | L.Schmidt, S.Sijersen | Gwen Meyer | ||
| 1983 | Barb Cothren | 8-12 | .400 | Jill Misener | Pam Wortman | ||
| 1984 | Barb Cothren | 5-15 | .250 | Gwen Meyer | Maryvel Bartlett | ||
| 1985 | Barb Cothren | 6-14 | .300 | Deb Thorman | Dawn Carlson | ||
| 1986 | Barb Cothren | 8-11 | .421 | Beth Mulberry | Deb Stranger | ||
| 1987 | Barb Cothren | 14-14 | .500 | 8-4 | .667 | Michelle Blair | Kelly Kramer |
| 1988 | Barb Cothren | 9-19 | .322 | 0-12 | .000 | Carolyn Albert | Sue Bierdz |
| 1989 | Mandy Neal | 13-18 | .419 | 3-9 | .250 | Kelly Kramer | Kim Hefner |
| 1990 | Mandy Neal | 20-16 | .556 | 6-6 | .500 | Carolyn Albert | Theresa Witte |
| 1991 | Mandy Neal | 31-7 | .816 | 14-2 * | .875 | Missy McEndree | Jennifer Jancik |
| 1992 | Mandy Neal | 23-9 | .719 | 11-5 | .688 | Gwynne Roberts | Amy Dzuris |
| 1993 | Mandy Neal | 19-12 | .613 | 11-3 | .786 | Donna Panatera, Sue Lammel | Lori Brown |
| 1994 | Mandy Neal | 34-9 # | .791 | 13-1 * | .929 | Jenny Miller | Robin Reed, Jenny Siron |
| 1995 | Mandy Neal | 30-14 | .682 | 12-2 * | .857 | Linda Borchew | Keri Miles |
| 1996 | Mandy Neal | 26-21 # | .553 | 12-2 $ | .857 | Linda Borchew, Jenny Siron | Amy Pollitz |
| 1997 | Mandy Neal | 27-14 | .659 | 12-2 $ | .857 | Kristin Stankus, Amy Pollitz | Erin Morley |
| 1998 | Mandy Neal | 25-13 | .658 | 8-5 | .615 | Jackie Kloiber | Jenny Hayes |
| 1999 | Mandy Neal | 27-12 | .688 | 9-5 | .643 | Sara Kummer, Jenny Hayes | Beth Keller |
| 2000 | Mandy Neal | 30-19 # | .612 | 8-6 $ | .571 | Stephanie Stephen | Sarah Englehardt |
| 2001 | Mandy Neal | 39-14 # | .736 | 8-6 $ | .571 | Sara Powers | Kelly Murray |
| 2002 | Beth Hasheider | 32-11 # | .744 | 12-2 * $ | .857 | Colleen Schuster | Ashley Patten |
| 2003 | Beth Hasheider | 38-8 # | .826 | 12-2 * $ | .857 | Brynn Hasse, Kelly Murray | Nicole Reed |
| 2004 | Beth Williams | 31-10 | .756 | 11-3 | .786 | Brynn Hasse | Molly Coers |
| 2005 | Beth Williams | 20-18 | .526 | 5-9 | .357 | Molly Coers | Lauren Hyland |
| 2006 | Lloyd Hulit | 32-12 | .727 | 12-2 | .857 | Katie Frawley | Katie Dobry |
| 2007 | Lloyd Hulit | 32-14 # | .696 | 13-1 * | .929 | Molly Coers | Valerie Hackett |
| 2008 | Steve King | 30-11 # | .732 | 12-2 * | .857 | Christy Engel | Natalie Chase |
| TOTALS | 32 seasons | 607-389-1 | .609 | 212-91 | .700 |
# - Indicates NCAA Division III tournament team - Go here for NCAA Results
* - Indicates CCIW regular season champion.
$ - Indicates CCIW postseason tourney champion.